Monday, February 7, 2011

Heathcliff the original Grinch?

When I started to contemplate what I had read in Wuthering Heights, and what to write in this blog I found my thoughts turning to The Grinch.  Not so much the original cartoon as the newer version starring Jim Carrey.  I would never have expected to compare the two, but it rings of the same premise.  The Grinch had been raised in a community that had rejected him because he did not look like the others in Whoville.  He was green and hairy and slightly unkempt looking with all of his facial hair.  The Who's were a delightful looking people and looked down on the young Grinch often causing him great unhappiness.  He was teased, and taunted, never accepted, but admired by one girl (sorry, I can't remember her name).  Heathcliff, being dark haired, dark skinned, and having a dark mood was also different from the family his "father" brought him home to.  In both of these stories the main character is rejected by the whole for being different.  They both suffered with internal strife for the love they felt for the only females that would capture their hearts.  But this love was unacceptable, and the women turned their affections to men who were acceptable to the society they grew in.  Wracked with such pain Heathcliff and the Grinch exiled themselves outside of the community until the time was right to return.  Their hearts, in the meantime, were filled with such hatred for those who chastised them, and they were focused on revenge. 

2 comments:

  1. Hi Kathleen!

    I really enjoyed the comparison you drew between Heathcliff and the Grinch. I honestly never would have thought of it myself. As I was reading your blog post, I kept nodding my head in agreement with the things you said.

    The only thing I thought to bring up is that the love Cindy Lou Who (definitely not how you spell it I'm sure) had for the Grinch is similar to the love Catherine initially felt for Heathcliff. However, I believe the love Catherine felt grew into her being in love with Heathcliff. Cindy Lou Who never transitioned into that kind of love for the Grinch.

    Other than that, it was a delightful comparison! :-)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Heathcliff, unlike the Grinch, actually had a redeeming quality within him before his return to his home. His love for Catherine should have made him more responsive to turning his anger around, but it seemed to have the opposite effect. The Grinch felt no connection to the people who had shunned him and still was able to change his attitude, but I'm guessing that is because it's a childrens story instead of a nineteenth century novel. Either way the two have eerie similarities and I wonder whether or not they are both a character type that has been used for centuries to tell very similar stories of redemption and revenge.

    ReplyDelete